+- Mock (https://mockforums.net)
+-- Forum: Serious Shit? (https://mockforums.net/forum-4.html)
+--- Forum: Assholes In The News (https://mockforums.net/forum-10.html)
+--- Thread: Bob Dylan a great singer???? (/thread-2151.html)
Pages:
1
2
- Maggot - 11-12-2008
Yup thats what the new Rolling Stone poll comes up with, he is placed at #7 WTF were they thinking? He is a great songwriter but he really sucks at singing. Aretha Franklin is #1 thats OK I guess. But Dylan.....::rollseyes::
- Sinister - 11-12-2008
That's like saying Jimi Hendrix is a better singer than guitar player. Who the fuck at Rolling Stone came up with this list, and how much dope has he smoked??? ::blink::
- Maggot - 11-12-2008
Here is the link http://music.yahoo.com/read/news/61852568
- Duchess - 11-12-2008
Aretha Franklin is as big as a volkswagon now.
- Maggot - 11-12-2008
Duchess Wrote:Aretha Franklin is as big as a volkswagon now.
Welllllllllll if she got a job where you get paged to walk the half fucking mile to get from one end of the fuckin bld to the other, just to page the person she was just fuckin talking to half a fucking mile away when the first time the right person was fucking paged would have worked.... she would only be as fat as a Ford escort.::angrier::
- Middle Finger - 11-12-2008
LMPP will appreciate my effort in providing unflattering pics of a celeb:
![[Image: aretha-franklin-picture-1.jpg]](http://images.askmen.com/galleries/singer/aretha-franklin/pictures/aretha-franklin-picture-1.jpg)
![[Image: aretha-franklin.jpg]](http://www.bilerico.com/2008/05/aretha-franklin.jpg)
![[Image: 18383488-18383491-slarge.jpg]](http://i.realone.com/assets/rn/img/8/8/4/3/18383488-18383491-slarge.jpg)
- Duchess - 11-12-2008
Well Jesus Christ, Maggot..You're pissed 'cuz I dissed Aretha...Someone who cares about her should have told her that long ago..She's suffocating her heart, dipshit.
- Maggot - 11-12-2008
Duchess Wrote:Well Jesus Christ, Maggot..You're pissed 'cuz I dissed Aretha...Someone who cares about her should have told her that long ago..She's suffocating her heart, dipshit.No! That was me that did all the walking, because my nextel is dead.But if she got a job doing it she would not be so fat. I love her voice.
- Maggot - 11-12-2008
I think MF is lovering her tits though.....
- Duchess - 11-12-2008
Maggot Wrote:I beg your pardon then..I would never insult the voice of the Queen Of Soul...just her fat ass.Duchess Wrote:Well Jesus Christ, Maggot..You're pissed 'cuz I dissed Aretha...Someone who cares about her should have told her that long ago..She's suffocating her heart, dipshit.No! That was me that did all the walking, because my nextel is dead.But if she got a job doing it she would not be so fat. I love her voice.
- The Antagonist - 11-13-2008
Not for nuthin' but whether you like the band or not, Joey Ramone had a very beautiful voice.
Every time I hear the Ramones I wax nostalgic to hear them live again. All of them are dead except for Tommy I think.
- Liquid - 11-13-2008
Maggot Wrote:Yup thats what the new Rolling Stone poll comes up with, he is placed at #7 WTF were they thinking? He is a great songwriter but he really sucks at singing. Aretha Franklin is #1 thats OK I guess. But Dylan.....::rollseyes::What about Ton Loc? - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=387ZDGSKVSg
Great voice.
RE: Bob Dylan a great singer???? - Maggot - 02-14-2019
I miss Aretha but am glad Gladys Knight still has a great voice.
RE: Bob Dylan a great singer???? - pyropappy - 02-14-2019
I saw Dylan in concert in 1978, lets just say he was a great song writer and when in the studio they could do wonders with his vocals for the recording, Live left a bit to be desired.
RE: Bob Dylan a great singer???? - sally - 02-15-2019
Is music theory needed to write songs?
RE: Bob Dylan a great singer???? - pyropappy - 02-15-2019
(02-15-2019, 12:09 AM)sally Wrote: Is music theory needed to write songs?
necessary, my guess is no, but it wouldn't hurt
RE: Bob Dylan a great singer???? - pyropappy - 02-15-2019
case in point: Amazing Grace: the true story of the conversion of its composer
written in the late 1770's by John Newton. Newton had no musical training, in fact he was a wretched man Conscripted in the Royall Navy as a young man, he lived a life of debauchery as most sailors do. When his service was over he became a slave trader. In the late 1740's he was on a vessel off the coast of Ireland during a violent storm that battered the vessel severely. That experience started his conversion to Christianity; in the mid 1750's he stopped slaving and left the sea for good. He started studying Theology, and was ordained in 1764. He has written many hymns, but Amazing Grace is known all over the world.
So I guess all you need is proper motivation or the right inspiration to write a song.
Every one has heard Amazing Grace, but how many knew the story of its creator?
RE: Bob Dylan a great singer???? - sally - 02-15-2019
I've of course heard the song, but did not know the story of the writer. I asked about music theory because my husband and son actually started to get into a heated argument about it earlier. I said jesus christ who gives a fuck and left the room. Then I figured this thread was a good place to mention it. If BG was around he'd probably have a say.
RE: Bob Dylan a great singer???? - BigMark - 02-15-2019
She wanted a pearl necklace, it didn't cost nuthin but it sure was fun.
RE: Bob Dylan a great singer???? - Blindgreed1 - 02-21-2019
Music Theory is not required to write songs. Some believe it helps with continuity, others say it's too restrictive. I'm of the opinion that whatever works for a particular writer works because the audience is where the rubber meets the road. If they like it and you've employed music theory then that works for that audience, but on the other hand we have "mumble rap" now which doesn't employ music theory, or even most conventional music standards on the whole, but their audience is eating it up. *shruggs* I've had 2 years of music theory. I lost interest.