Would Jew Take Him Out?

[Cynical Ninja]

Is it okay to kill a person who will kill others? Or are you Troy Davis?

It would depend on how much of the future I had knowledge of. Kind of like do you want to stick with the devil you know, or go with a devil you don't know?

Say you had the chance to change one piece of history, (for example, kill off Hitler as a baby), and you could foresee what the alternate reality would be, (maybe a more viscous ruler is put into Hitler's place-some who not only kills Jews, but also goes after 10 other nationalities). Would you still kill Hitler, knowing his replacement is going to cause a million more deaths?



This is a really intriguing question, Cracker, you got my mind going in 5 different directions. Good thread.

Nazism would have happened without Hitler, who's to say the alternative fuhrer wouldn't have been even more bloodthirsty and killed more jews than him?

You people need to check out the Back to the Future trilogy and Chaos theory to understand why you should never change the past even if the intention is to do good.