NFL 2014

[Cutz]

A healthy RGIII had a chance to be pretty special.

That's the linchpin of every mobile QB. 5 years ago you could be saying, "A healthy Mike Vick has a chance to be special" and nobody would disagree. Personally I think Colin Kaepernick has proven more than RG3 to this point, but neither is close to as proven as Brady.

I put Peyton ahead just because he does more from the QB position. If you hire P. Manning, you can basically fire your offensive coordinator. Peyton just makes defenses look stupid at the LOS.
Aaron Rodgers gets the nod for me for accuracy and awareness. I've seen too impressive back-shoulder throws to say he's not the best from a ball-placement perspective. When you put a ball literally where only your receiver can get it, you make your offense very hard to counter.