The immunity is for the Board of Lucas County Commissioners, and their agents. There is some code preventing use of 911 tapes and the prosecutor is asking that immunity be given to the keepers of the tapes. That's all.

ADUB, Thanks for the info !

(01-09-2013, 01:12 PM)Adub Wrote: The immunity is for the Board of Lucas County Commissioners, and their agents. There is some code preventing use of 911 tapes and the prosecutor is asking that immunity be given to the keepers of the tapes. That's all.

Ohio does not consider audible 911 tapes not public record???? Why would a political entity need immunity for such information?

(01-10-2013, 03:01 AM)Sphincter Cop Wrote:

(01-09-2013, 01:12 PM)Adub Wrote: The immunity is for the Board of Lucas County Commissioners, and their agents. There is some code preventing use of 911 tapes and the prosecutor is asking that immunity be given to the keepers of the tapes. That's all.

Ohio does not consider audible 911 tapes not public record???? Why would a political entity need immunity for such information?

Calls to 911 are public records. The media has access to them. Not sure why the need to ask for immunity for public officials. But the judge granted immunity and the prosecutor will present the tapes as evidence against Pettaway.

May have something to do with the victim refusing to testify? None of it makes sense to me, just hoping that Pettaway is held to answer for beating on this stoopid twat. The hospital records should seal the deal.

Pretrial Inspection and Request for Immunity

Lt. Twinnings TPD has been ordered to produce said objects for pretrial.

Here is the MEMORANDUM abbreviated.

All telephone calls made to Lucas County 911 in response to emergency situations are tape recorded by the agency. These tapes are then maintained by the agency in the regular course of the business. Ohio Revised Code Section 4931 49(E) states.

No person shall disclose or use, for any purpose other than for the 9-1-1 system, any information contained in the data base of the phone network.

So various Ohio Revised codes are in place here and if they are violated you can be fined 300 dollars or imprisoned up to 90 days thats the first offense for each subsequent offense, such a person is guilty of a felony of the third degree.

Therefor, compliance with the current request could subject the Board of County Commissioners of Lucas County and their agents and employees, Lt. Brian Twinnings, and employees of Toledo Police Department Communications to criminal sanctions.

So everyone from the Commissioners, their agents and employees, Lt. Brian Twinnings and the employees of TPD Communications Section be granted immunity. Further, that the immunity hereby sought be extended to any employee of the TPD Communications Section who is subpoenaed and testifies concerning the material sought by the request.

Gosh I hope this helps a little.

And this ??

1/15/2013 1 Title : MIS:CASE CONT AT DEF REQUEST
72-000022065 issued by 203 ()
Dated January 15, 2013. Court Reporter DOUG ACKERMAN
ordered. State of Ohio: MARK HERR. KURT W BRUDERLY
present on behalf of the defendant. Defendant, CAMEO
PETTAWAY present in court.
Matter called for Pretrial. Defendant requests time to
retain counsel. Pursuant to the request of Defendant
matter rescheduled for Pretrial and Appearance of Retained
Counsel on January 28, 2013 at 1:00 p.m. Trial date of
January 22, 2013 vacated at the request of the defendant.
Bond is continued.
JUDGE STACY L COOK
PARTY : D1 - PETTAWAY CAMEO

(01-17-2013, 01:22 AM)Older Than Dirt Wrote: And this ??

1/15/2013 1 Title : MIS:CASE CONT AT DEF REQUEST
72-000022065 issued by 203 ()
Dated January 15, 2013. Court Reporter DOUG ACKERMAN
ordered. State of Ohio: MARK HERR. KURT W BRUDERLY
present on behalf of the defendant. Defendant, CAMEO
PETTAWAY present in court.
Matter called for Pretrial. Defendant requests time to
retain counsel. Pursuant to the request of Defendant
matter rescheduled for Pretrial and Appearance of Retained
Counsel on January 28, 2013 at 1:00 p.m. Trial date of
January 22, 2013 vacated at the request of the defendant.
Bond is continued.
JUDGE STACY L COOK
PARTY : D1 - PETTAWAY CAMEO

Good grief! did Kurt W Bruderly quit? or did Pettaway find another Lawyer?

Maybe he wants the lawyer who set him free !

Can a lawyer just remove themselves? I didn't think they could I tout they had to go to the courts and prove why they wanted to and have good reason once they have taken on the case? But if the client fires them that is or would be something different and the courts would give him more time to find an attorney. Either way I would think if the courts agreed to remove the attorney or if he fired the attorney I would think the courts would give him time. I just hope this doesn't continue, become a pattern and become a stall tatitic. How many times can you get a new attorney for your case?

(01-17-2013, 02:57 PM)heartbreaker6713 Wrote: Can a lawyer just remove themselves? How many times can you get a new attorney for your case?

An attorney can motion a court to be removed from a case. The final word on why he/she can or cannot will be with the Judge. The attorney would have to have a really good reason as to why.

A defendant has a right to terminate the services of an attorney.

However, if it becomes apparent that this is holding up court proceedings or delaying the case; the Judge can stop this type of "game playing" by a defendant. The case will proceed with whatever attorney or court appointed attorney is on the case. Of course, I am sure this could go to the appellate level if the defendant loses. I am sure a good judge on a case would make sure that the defendant gets the most out of his defense.


***I hope that detectives and prosecutors have not given up on the Clarke/Straub homicide. It would be great if someone is not giving up after only one conviction. The dismissal is so disgusting on the pettaway side of the case. I still do not understand that, and LC was perplexed by it as well.

so, is his trial supposed to start monday? or is that just when he presents a new lawyer?

Pre Trial for Cameo Pettaway is set for 4^th February 2013 at 1 p.m. Pettaway appeared in Court 28^th January 2013,Attorney Kurt W Bruderly granted leave to withdraw as Counsel. Attorney Rebecca West-Estell retained, Frank Simmons present on behalf of Rebecca West-Estell.

On www.Avvo.com you can find a Lawyer and review a Lawyer, Kurt W Bruderly had an amazing review.

West-Estell is a black woman.

(01-29-2013, 04:31 PM)Adub Wrote: West-Estell is a black woman.

The lady specializes in Bankruptcy.

Night Owl, you beat me to it ! I just copied and was ready to post. I really like how you can sum things up !!!

(01-29-2013, 04:49 PM)NightOwl Wrote:

(01-29-2013, 04:31 PM)Adub Wrote: West-Estell is a black woman.

The lady specializes in Bankruptcy.

Some of her criminal clients have made the news

http://www.toledoblade.com/Courts/2012/0...lling.html

http://www.toledoblade.com/Courts/2012/0...opens.html

TWO YEARS LATER


In Loving Memory of Johnny S. Clarke Yes i totally agree they failed us that dreadfull cold evil vile night in everyway tearssss but the first responsible are the hoodrats that were on phone with lisa and heard johnny screaming twice the same loud screams for help and then phone communications were lost and those vile demons did nothing to help them or call the cops trust me i will get them too bc if they had called police my son and lisa would be alive today so they too are guilty as sin and set up mfkin rats
3 minutes ago via


In Loving Memory of Johnny S. Clarke
4 hours ago via mobile
Shortly before 11pm this vile hoodrat demon and her pill head bf were on the phone with lisa and heard my son screaming WHO THE F ARE YOU? WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE? WHAT DO YOU WANT? and cell phone communications were lost and this hoodrats never called the cops they waited till after 1am to tell someone to call us and say they thought something bad happened to my son and lisa :,( I HATE YOU AND YOU TWO WILL PAY FOR BEING PART OF THE TORTURE OF OUR KID AND WORST NIGHTMARE OF OUR LIFES!!!

This is the 2^nd anniversary of Johnny and Lisa - Maytee is re-visiting that hellish night!


Justice for Johnny Clarke and Lisa Straub
4 hours ago via mobile

"Shortly before 11pm this vile hoodrat demon and her pill head bf were on the phone with lisa and heard my son screaming WHO THE F ARE YOU? WHAT ARE YOU DOING HERE? WHAT DO YOU WANT? and cell phone communications were lost and this hoodrats never called the cops they waited till after 1am to tell someone to call us and say they thought something bad happened to my son and lisa :,( I HATE YOU AND YOU TWO WILL PAY FOR BEING PART OF THE TORTURE OF OUR KID AND WORST NIGHTMARE OF OUR LIFES!!!"


By this time we had already called the sherriffs twice to help us and had the hoodrat demon vile pillheads trapped in driveway to tell the police what they heard on the phone and how the cell phones lost all communications shortly before 11pm and both time the police there with us and failed us to go in lisa house to do a welfare check so when they left shortly after 3am we took matters in our own hands my hubby kicked in door to find our poor kids tortured lifeless TEARSSSSSSS THATS THE DAY I LOST MYSELF AND THE DEVASTATION IN MY HEART LIFE MIND AND SOUL BEGAN totally consumed with sadness anger rage hatred i can hear my husbands screams echoing into space in disbelief tears i fainted waking up to yelow tape ambulance sherriffs beating on one asking why they failed us twice and not save our kids :,( </3


Justice for Johnny Clarke and Lisa Straub In absolute despair anguish disbelief my hubby tried cpr on both kids and ive never heard him scream crying so loud is total despair and anguish at what he endured as he walked in the house i ran towards house fainting half way to the door OH LORD WHYYYYYYYYYY WHERE WERE YOU WHEN JOHNNY AND LISA NEEDED YOU THE MOST :,( </3 :"( </3
28 minutes ago via mobile · Like

OlderThanDirt I was only 1 minute behind you I must stop dawdling!

In Loving Memory of Johnny S. Clarke
34 minutes ago via mobile
By this time we had already called the sherriffs twice to help us and had the hoodrat demon vile pillheads trapped in driveway to tell the police what they heard on the phone and how the cell phones lost all communications shortly before 11pm and both time the police there with us and failed us to go in lisa house to do a welfare check so when they left shortly after 3am we took matters in our own hands my hubby kicked in door to find our poor kids tortured lifeless TEARSSSSSSS THATS THE DAY I LOST MYSELF AND THE DEVASTATION IN MY HEART LIFE MIND AND SOUL BEGAN totally consumed with sadness anger rage hatred i can hear my husbands screams echoing into space in disbelief tears i fainted waking up to yelow tape ambulance sherriffs beating on one asking why they failed us twice and not save our kids :,( </3